From Urban Encounter to Archival Record (Munné, Pol, Pellicer, Di Masso, Blanke, Pineo) · LAPIEZA LAB · Anto Lloveras · Socioplastics · 2026


Evidence does not pre-exist the route by which it becomes apprehensible. It is composed within an encounter among a material setting, a social position, an available vocabulary and an apparatus of registration. The proposition seems straightforward until the route ceases to mean a line across the city and begins to include the passage from sensation to statement, from statement to variable, and from variable to a durable record. At each passage, an experience acquires new capacities for comparison and loses some of the conditions that made it intelligible. This is not a reason to abandon comparison; it is a reason to specify its costs. Munné’s account of complexity is valuable precisely where different descriptions of one situation no longer agree on what its boundaries are. Fractal differentiation and fuzzy attribution challenge any assumption that a social unit has one natural scale, although they do not relieve the analyst of the task of choosing a defensible one. 


Urban environmental evaluation exposes this dilemma in operational terms. García-Mira, Sabucedo and Arce show that neighbourhood satisfaction is constituted through intersecting judgements concerning material provision, social relations and affective attachment; wanting to leave a neighbourhood need not simply invert satisfaction with it. A questionnaire is not discredited because it turns such judgements into variables. Its validity becomes more demanding: it must clarify which differences have been stabilised to permit the model to operate. Vidal, Pol, Guàrdia and Peró approach the same problem from the other direction. Appropriation of place is simultaneously enacted and interpreted, so that a resident’s habitual use, participation in collective projects and identification with a neighbourhood cannot be reduced without remainder to legal tenure or to the geometry of dwelling. Their structural model makes relations testable, but the model’s object is already implicated in the transformation of Trinitat Nova and in the unequal possibilities of acting upon it. Attachment must consequently be distinguished from inclusion. A group may acquire an intense relation to a site through practices that restrict the presence of others; the physical persistence of a use is not proof that it is socially legitimate. Di Masso, Berroeta and Vidal make this latent tension politically explicit. Public space is not first a universally accessible container subsequently disrupted by conflict. The designation of a place as public is itself an ongoing struggle over who may assemble, remain, speak, be visible or exercise control. Spatial order can be produced through the exclusion of claims that would otherwise count as evidence of that order’s deficiencies. Hence an observational record of a quiet square, even if precise, is incomplete unless it asks how quietness has been organised and whose absence made it possible. The question is not whether the city can be known objectively in some simple oppositional sense; it is which procedures render one account authoritative while others remain unrecognised. Valera relocates the problem within the transformation of an observation into a network. The activities of a public square become relations through registered co-occurrences, and their varying centralities reveal how observed uses change across successive periods of a day. Yet the network’s apparent precision does not remove the judgement involved in defining events, variables and observational windows; a central node is not necessarily an inclusive or politically legitimate practice. Its value is to disclose a relational configuration rather than merely enumerate activities. The 2026 analysis by Pellicer Cardona and colleagues poses a complementary challenge to the act of observation itself, making this requirement unusually concrete. Its three studies reveal how a route negotiated with a participant may disclose an avoided street, a lost bench, a bodily hesitation or a social demand that would not arise in a detached interview. The five transversal processes separate spatial authority, timing, copresence, material encounter and practical contradiction so that movement may be analysed rather than romanticised. Yet the act of accompanying another body also creates exposure. Walking can reactivate vulnerability, privilege those who are physically able to participate, or allow the researcher’s own capacities and social position to redirect a story. These are not secondary ethical reservations imposed after knowledge production; they shape the knowledge that can be produced. At this point, the relation between evidence and public space becomes reciprocal. A route makes urban conflicts reportable, while an already contested public realm determines which routes, bodies and accounts are possible. What is missing from an interview may therefore be as consequential as what is transcribed, but absence cannot automatically be recoded as a positive finding. It demands a careful description of the conditions under which an observation was impossible, refused or displaced. The shared lesson is not that every perspective is equally adequate. It is that the operations by which adequacy is judged must remain accountable to situated differences. Any inference about the city is simultaneously a claim about the instrument, permission and position from which the city could be encountered.


Once an encounter has been stabilised as a record, another route begins: the route through an archive, catalogue, database, interface and public search. This passage does not merely transmit findings from field to reader. It establishes the units by which they will be retrieved and the relations under which they can be compared. A neighbourhood transcript filed under safety, a photograph classified as infrastructure, and a refusal to be interviewed recorded only as missing data enter different epistemic economies, even when they arise from the same walk. Their separation may be administratively necessary, but it also has a politics. Blanke’s counter-archiving demonstrates that the arrangement of documentary material is never exhausted by its initial institutional purpose. Tribunal decisions composed to adjudicate cases can be reassembled to disclose fragments of everyday experience; a web archive built through successive captures can be interrogated through trajectories and relations not anticipated by its original indexing. Such transformations create possible histories without yielding an archive innocent of interpretation. They require explicit choices about collection, cleaning, grouping, temporal comparison and the interpretive role assigned to computational procedures. This is where the field route and the archival route meet. Neither should be mistaken for an uninterrupted chain of transparent evidence. Every conversion has a threshold: when a gesture becomes a note, when a note becomes a code, when a code becomes a keyword, when a keyword becomes the principal access point for a document. Socioplastics, as a constructed corpus of conceptual markers and comparative urban inquiries, can treat these thresholds as part of its material rather than as an invisible service layer. A marker may preserve a distinctive proposition, but a consistent name does not guarantee that its historical occasions of use remain accessible. For the corpus to sustain critical comparison, the relation between a conceptual term and the documents in which it is defined, revised or disputed should be legible without requiring those documents to be reduced to a single explanatory category. The same caution applies to geolocation. A point on a map can anchor a claim spatially while suppressing the itinerary, temporal exposure and negotiated permission through which the point acquired significance. A robust record would distinguish the site of observation from the route of encounter; the date of an event from the date of interpretation; a participant’s account from an institutional description; an original language from an editorial translation; and a documented relation from a later analytical hypothesis. These distinctions are not demands for encyclopaedic metadata. They establish a minimum grammar of provenance capable of making changes in classification inspectable. Cugliana and colleagues’ computational philology gives the principle a rigorous analogy. When a graph models editorial decisions instead of representing only a settled text, authority becomes a relation that can be examined, amended and partly reproduced. The glyph model is specific to textual scholarship, and its assumptions should not be imposed on living urban situations. Its transferable insight is narrower and more powerful: a representation gains epistemic value when some of the reasoning that assembled it is available for scrutiny. An archival apparatus can therefore preserve not just a result, but the fact that a result depended on a particular operation. Yet transparency is not universal disclosure. The publication of detailed routes, identities or encounters can expose participants whose accounts were collected under different expectations of circulation. A responsible infrastructure must allow distinctions between public, restricted and withheld materials; an absence in the searchable archive should not automatically be treated as the absence of a corresponding event. Pineo adds a further, frequently neglected asymmetry. Even a publicly released record may be practically unreachable if the search path is illogical, its interface inaccessible, or its description cannot be read. Discoverability, usability and readability are separate obligations, and they do not collapse into the possession of a persistent identifier. For Socioplastics this means that a DOI, a conceptual title and an indexed entry can establish traceability, but not yet meaningful access; equally, an accessible interface does not establish the validity of what it makes visible. The question of public legibility thus requires more than maximising visibility. It requires navigable relations among document, context and revision, alongside a defensible account of what should remain opaque. Such an architecture would permit comparative fieldwork without assuming that distinct neighbourhoods, bodies and methods produce interchangeable data. It would register whether a claim arises from counting, walking, mapping, interpretation or collective dispute, and it would preserve enough of the passage among those operations for another reader to challenge an inference. A conceptual archive built on these terms would not present its growth as proof of knowledge. Its strength would be the capacity to expose how an apparent equivalence was made and where it breaks down. Urban research, archival description and digital circulation would then be connected by accountable transformations rather than by the fiction of seamless integration. Within Socioplastics, the resistance disclosed at these passages between situated encounter, classification and public retrieval is condensed by the existing operator KnowledgeFriction.


Anto Lloveras works across architecture, urbanism and critical epistemology. Through LAPIEZA LAB, his research examines the relations among spatial fieldwork, documentary construction, conceptual classification and the infrastructures through which urban knowledge is organised and circulated.



BIBLIOGRAPHY


Blanke, T. (2024) ‘Reassembling digital archives—strategies for counter-archiving’, Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 11, article 201. doi:10.1057/s41599-024-02668-4.


Cugliana, E., Ward, A., van Zundert, J.J., Kuczera, A. and Grüntgens, M. (2024) ‘Computational approaches and the epistemology of scholarly editing’, International Journal of Digital Humanities, 6, pp. 169–188. doi:10.1007/s42803-024-00088-z.


Di Masso, A., Berroeta, H. and Vidal, T. (2017) ‘El espacio público en conflicto: coordenadas conceptuales y tensiones ideológicas’, Athenea Digital, 17(3), pp. 53–92. doi:10.5565/rev/athenea.1725.


García-Mira, R., Sabucedo, J.M. and Arce, C. (1996) ‘Evaluación de la calidad ambiental urbana’, Revista de Psicología Social, 11(2), pp. 235–252.


Munné, F. (2004) ‘El retorno de la complejidad y la nueva imagen del ser humano: hacia una psicología compleja’, Revista Interamericana de Psicología / Interamerican Journal of Psychology, 38(1), pp. 23–31. Available at: http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=28438104.


Pellicer Cardona, I., Quilez Relaño, G., Morales Piris, E., Gómez Terradas, M.M. and Araya Vera, M. (2026) ‘Al ritmo de la ciudad: potencial crítico y epistemología espacial de las entrevistas en movimiento’, Psicoperspectivas, 25(3). doi:10.5027/psicoperspectivas-vol25-issue3-fulltext-3841.


Pineo, E.A. (2025) ‘Discoverability, usability, and readability: a framework for assessing accessibility for disabled users of online archives’, Archival Science, 25, article 25. doi:10.1007/s10502-025-09495-9.


Valera, S. (2019) ‘El espacio público como red. Una aproximación entre la Psicología Ambiental y el Análisis de Redes Sociales’, REDES. Revista Hispana para el Análisis de Redes Sociales, 31(1), pp. 30–45. doi:10.5565/rev/redes.843.


Vidal, T., Pol, E., Guàrdia, J. and Peró, M. (2004) ‘Un modelo de apropiación del espacio mediante ecuaciones estructurales’, Medio Ambiente y Comportamiento Humano, 5(1–2), pp. 27–52.